I couldn’t care less if Star Wars really counts as science fiction or not (Jeffro has that covered anyway) but Bruce Bethke has something else in his post which is even stupider:
But if you’re an adult, then it really comes down to just one question: either you really love the way J. J. Abrams makes new movies for the new generation by mashing up scenes, samples, and even entire set pieces lifted whole from movies you loved when you were young—only bigger, longer, and louder in the Abrams Remix—or you don’t. If you loved what Abrams did with the recent Star Trek reboot, or loved Star Wars: The Force Awakens, you will love this movie. If not—
Well, it’s still a fun ride and worth watching, but wait for the Blu-Ray. Your bladder will thank you.
No, it’s not worth watching and Abrams is an overrated hack. George Lucas was a mash up artist. He was a genius at before he got stupid and decided he was smart enough to do his own thing. Abrams is garbage. Almost everything he’s done is garbage. For Star Wars and Star Trek he simply took the universe he was supposed to work in, hacked recognizable pieces out of them, and sewed them back together in a drooling, shambling Frankenstein.
There is only one thing that Abrams has done that I actually like: Fringe. And Fringe is a horrifically flawed show which ended badly and the fourth season should have been erased from existence (and if they’d ended it right would have been). Someone I once knew, back when the show first came out, said it wasn’t worth watching because it was “just an X-Files rip off.” I thought she meant it was about FBI agents investigating paranormal stuff. Oh, no. That was before I’d seen X-Files. The pilot of Fringe is X-Files season 5, episode 18, “The Pine Bluff Variant.” It’s one thing to steal an idea or two. It’s another to take so much that the end product is instantly recognizable as its source matter.
As previously noted, I might be able to watch Yojimbo and instantly see a scene that Lucas took and turned into the cantina scene from A New Hope and I might see a similarity between C-3PO and R2-D2 and the peasants in The Hidden Fortress but the original trilogy was what a mash up is supposed to be: its own thing. Just as Yojimbo itself is its own thing but A Fist Full of Dollars is not. A Fist Full of Dollars, however, is an honest remake and a good movie. The Force Awakens isn’t. It tries to lie to you, to pretend be something new, but the seams show and the monster drools too much. The Last Jedi is even worse.